Snow, Ice, and Wind Damage: Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles

Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles in Burr Ridge: Considering a roof upgrade? If you’re choosing between asphalt shingles and metal for winter performance, this guide breaks down what truly lasts through snow, ice, and wind. Illinois winters bring freezing temperatures, snow buildup, and strong winds that can wear down traditional roofing materials.

Home-Resto has helped local homeowners identify which options hold up best over time. This comparison looks at durability, energy efficiency, cost, and long-term value. For those already dealing with leaks or storm issues, our roof replacement Burr Ridge IL can help you take action before small problems turn into bigger ones.

What to Expect From Asphalt Shingles in Winter

Homeowners often choose asphalt shingles because of their lower upfront cost and widespread availability among common roofing materials Burr Ridge IL residents consider. But when Midwest winters arrive, bringing freeze-thaw cycles, snow buildup, and cold winds, the limitations of asphalt start to show.

Cracking And Granule Loss

In temperatures below freezing, older shingles may become brittle. As snow melts and refreezes, granules loosen and the protective surface wears down, making the shingles more vulnerable to leaks and deterioration.

Wind Damage Susceptibility

Standard asphalt shingles are typically rated to resist winds of 60–80 mph. In a strong Illinois storm, that threshold can be exceeded—resulting in shingle blow-offs, curling edges, and exposed underlayment.

Lifespan Expectations in Illinois

In the Burr Ridge climate, asphalt roofs often last 15–20 years, but that number can drop depending on winter severity and maintenance. Small issues like ice damming or flashing degradation can evolve into more expensive repairs over time.

How Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles Handle Ice and Wind

Metal roofing systems outperform traditional shingles when it comes to withstanding heavy snowfall, fluctuating temperatures, and high wind events. They’ve become increasingly popular in Burr Ridge, especially among homeowners seeking durability and low maintenance.

What Makes Metal More Winter-Resistant:

• The smooth surface allows snow and ice to slide off easily, reducing static weight and lowering the chance of roof collapse in extreme snow events.
  
  

• Most metal roofs are rated to withstand wind speeds up to 140 mph. That makes a difference during Midwest winter storms, where gusts often exceed 60 mph. FEMA’s building science recommendations also support reinforced roofing systems in areas vulnerable to wind uplift and ice accumulation.
  
  

• Interlocking panel designs and hidden fastener systems help prevent water intrusion, even during rapid freeze-thaw transitions.

A properly installed metal roof with underlayment can last 40 to 70 years, nearly doubling the lifespan of asphalt. Fewer repairs and less winter wear make this a longer-term investment for Burr Ridge properties.

Energy Efficiency & Insulation Factors

Winter performance isn’t just about how a material holds up structurally. Heating costs in Illinois homes are directly impacted by how well a roof helps regulate indoor temperature.

Metal Roof Advantages:

• Reflects solar heat during the day, keeping attic temperatures more stable and reducing the risk of condensation.

• Helps prevent ice dams by maintaining a uniform temperature across the roof surface, especially when paired with ridge vents and proper soffit airflow.

• 
  

Asphalt Roof Effects:

• Absorbs sunlight, which can assist with minor snow melt. But this same absorption contributes to uneven thawing, which often leads to ice dam formation at roof edges.

• Once moisture gets under the shingle layers, the freeze-thaw cycle can worsen existing leaks or expose unsealed areas.

Upgrading attic insulation and ensuring clean ventilation paths are essential steps—no matter which material is installed.

CTA: Don’t wait for the next snowstorm to expose your roof’s weak spots. Schedule a roofing consultation with Home-Resto and get practical solutions tailored to your Burr Ridge home’s needs before winter issues escalate.

Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles Cost Over 20 Years

Initial cost matters, but long-term reliability and upkeep play a bigger role in total roof value. Many Burr Ridge homeowners now evaluate roofing as a 20-year investment instead of just a one-time expense.

Photos and documented roof inspections can reduce insurance denial rates for storm claims. Home-Resto’s roof service plan includes a photo database updated every four months, helping protect your investment and support future claims.

Our Recommendation Based on Home Type

Every Burr Ridge home has its own architectural demands, and roofing choices should reflect both structure and lifestyle.

Steep-Pitched Roofs

Homes with sharp roof angles benefit from metal's snow-shedding ability. Snow doesn’t sit long enough to freeze, melt, and form damaging ice dams.

Older Properties

Many homes built before 1980 may not have the rafter strength to support snow buildup. Choosing metal shingles Burr Ridge IL can relieve stress on these older frames while keeping a classic appearance.

New Builds And Remodels

Modern construction typically includes improved insulation, open soffits, and attic venting. Metal works well in these homes, offering longer lifespan and added value on resale.

Aesthetic Or HOA Limits

Some subdivisions in Burr Ridge still prefer traditional looks. Today’s coated metal shingles closely mimic wood shake and asphalt profiles, meeting aesthetic standards while outperforming traditional materials.

Whether you’re planning a full roof replacement or need immediate roof repair Burr Ridge IL, Home-Resto can help you make a confident, winter-ready choice.

Choosing the Right Roof for Burr Ridge Winters

Choosing between metal roofs and asphalt shingles involves more than upfront cost in roofing Burr Ridge IL homeowners trust for durability. Harsh Midwest winters bring snow, ice, wind, and freezing temperatures that test a roof’s strength. While asphalt may offer short-term savings, metal delivers longer-lasting protection with fewer repairs and better insurance outcomes. The right choice depends on your home’s structure, age, and goals.

Home-Resto focuses on performance that holds up year after year. Burr Ridge homeowners comparing roof repair options, reviewing the FAQ section, or checking our service areas can weigh durability, efficiency, and long-term value to protect their property through winter.

Need help deciding? Contact Home-Resto for a personalized roofing consultation and estimate in Burr Ridge today. Call (630) 242-2101 and take the next step toward lasting winter protection without second-guessing your decision.